Even the most ardent proponents of industrialism would acknowledge that we are in the midst of an environment crisis. Rates of species extinction are 1000 times more than what they were before human beings dominated the earth. The rate of carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere is 30 times more than when the Industrial revolution started. Urban India is slowly waking up to this inconvenient truth.
The Outlook-CNN-IBN-CSDS "State of Environment in Indian Cities" is an attempt to gauge precisely this- assess the level of awareness, attitudes, perception and concerns of the people about the state of environment in their country
The survey- has thrown up some startling results. Indians consider environment to be the Number Two problem beating unemployment, law and order and even corruption. In a similar survey conducted in the UK the British considered environment as Number Five on their list of social problems, which the government should tackle. Indians in the first ever environment poll are clearly feeling the heat.
Does this mean Indians are environmentally responsible? Being aware does not always translate into responsible action more than half - 53%don't segregate their garbage, 43% never switch off their lights. And they may not always be aware- 45% believe the biggest contributor to air pollution is industries and not their own private vehicles, 53% believe the main reason for pollution in the rivers is because of industrial waste - only 18% see a connection between their own sewage and the state of our rivers. A majority are willing to give up their cars if a better public transport is in place and would vote for a politician who promises a clean environment.
In the maze of high-rise apartments, glitzy shopping malls and lifestyle diseases urban India is also waking up to the perils of life in a rapidly concretizing jungle. Perhaps the biggest lesson from this survey is that for urban Indians environmental problems are no longer 'out there' -they are right here in our cities- wetlands which used to act as carbon sinks in cities are being built on, rivers like the Yamuna are dead, the once common house sparrows are now hard to see and gadgets like reverse osmosis, and inhalers are integral to every household in our cities. Drive just a few kilometers outside any city and the devastation is visible - a stark brown landscape and big craters in agricultural fields -soil being used as bricks for a city's high rise dreams.
But Indians are also fighting back. While Indian environmentalism was associated with rural Indians fighting to stop mass destruction of trees through the 'chipko movement' of in the 1980s- urban Indians are catching up- As the environment editor at CNN-IBN I am flooded with calls daily from a university professor fighting to save trees from being cut down, an RWA fighting against encroachments of green spaces by builders or an architect fighting to save the Yamuna. These are ordinary middle class Indians turned eco-warriors. They may use gandhian methods of dharnas, and agitations but they have access to other tools- sms campaigns and mass emails - they know how to work the government systems and the media to fight their green wars.
Sadly one institution which has not kept pace with this movement - the Ministry of Environment and Forests- in the dusty corridors of its innocuous building in South Delhi some of the most vital decisions are taken for destruction of this country's vital natural resources. Environment clearances are handed out like driver's licenses at your local RTO, on the basis of technical reports that conveniently overlook globally endangered wildlife species may inhabit the forests. To date - the Ministry has cleared every single project sent to it for environment and forest clearance. In other developing countries like Kenya or Brazil there is a fear of the Ministry and its policing institutions. Portfolios like environment are handed to articulate, savvy and strong politicians. Ask any person if they can recall even one environment minister of India - and their memories may fail.
Critics of environmentalism have so far brushed aside the movement is being too 'apocalyptic' or driven by a left agenda. But urban Indians have given their verdict- the deteriorating environment is a mainstream social issue. The environment is suddenly everyone's problem. As a young mother on the CNN-IBN State of the environment show put it- access to clean air should be declared an essential commodity. This World environment day perhaps its time to unleash Indian environmentalism from the shackles of being perceived as a jhola- clad activist's agenda to an essential service, which urban Indians want. The period of denial is over.
Total Comments: 34
Read Comment | Post Comment
Hello,
ReplyI am very happy to read your blog on environmentalism in India! I am a student at the George Washington University in Washington, DC and am writing a paper on environmentalism in India. I would be very interested in getting your opinion on a few question I have. Please let me know if you would be available to interview via email. Again, great blog!
Rachel
racheltrip@gmail.com ...
The biggest problem with Indian environmentalism is that "Many smart people have started using environmental crisis as an oportunity to earn quick money and fame."
ReplyThere are people working at grassroot level to deal with current environmental crisis but most often these true warrioirs are ignored.
...
The article is really nice and very nicely taken the environment problem. I think all of us knows about the environment issues..global warming...Politician and Industrialist knowns about the consequences and all of us are watching the effect of it.We have ruined our mother earth like anything.
ReplyWe just talk...All national and international NGOs are coming up with the issues and I think they are hardly doing anything on this.
Just by switching off the lights and taking bi-cycle is not the solution. First of all the license to the industries should be restricted. The major cause to the pollution is industry.
Let us hope to have a greener world. ...
environmental awreness is there. but there's no action happening. mining is taking its toll across the country. nothing is being done by ANY political party. we the citizens are stupid and mute witnesses. we need more awareness and a kick in the butt to ourselves. we need action. and now! ...
ReplyBahar, you speak of awareness about environmental hazards not necessarily translating into preventive action. This is more often the case than not. Tell me, do you car pool to work? How many companies and government offices in India encourage and make arrangements for virtual meetings and WFH policies to curb emission from vehicular and air traffic? Forget segregation of garbage. Look at our fancy new neighbouhood retail stores that dole out plastic bags by the dozen to every customer. How many apartments install solar heaters. I hear of a commercial buildings being built outside the country that will generate its own electricity from its mirror-panelled exterior. Is our government even 'mulling' such an example? How about the Bureau of Energy Efficiency? Laws that will ensure environmental protection have to be enforced. The ordinary citizen will never have the inclination or the time to make an extra effort for the environment. Perhaps all state governements should focus on improving the public transport system so that average city dwellers like you and I are able to commute to work via buses or trains, rather than fuel-guzzling, pollution-emitting cars. ...
ReplyRead More Comments
The views/ideas/opinions expressed in this section of the website www.ibnlive.com / www.ibnpolitics.com are solely those of the writer/author and not of Web18 Software Services Limited (Web18) or of IBN18 Broadcast Limited (IBN18). The statements made by the writer/author have not been verified in any manner by Web18 and/or IBN18. Web18 and/or IBN18 shall not be responsible for or liable in any manner whatsoever for the views/ideas/opinions expressed by the writer/author of this section.