IBNLive.com: Breaking news from India

Rajdeep Sardesai

Newsman

Rajdeep Sardesai

Rajdeep Sardesai comes with 20 years of journalistic experience during which he has covered the biggest political stories in India. Prior to setting up his own channels, he was the Managing Editor of both NDTV 24X7 and NDTV India and was responsible for overseeing the news policy for both the channels. He has also worked with The Times of India for over five years and was the city editor of its Mumbai edition at the age of 26. During the last 20 years, he has covered major national and international stories, specialising in national politics. He has won numerous other awards for journalistic excellence, including the prestigious Padma Shri for journalism in 2008, the International Broadcasters Award for coverage of the 2002 Gujarat riots and the Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Award for 2007. He has won the Asian Television Award for talk show presentation and has been News Anchor of the year at the Indian Television Academy for six of the last seven years. He is presently the President of the Editors Guild of India. He has done his Masters and LLB from Oxford University and has also played cricket for the Oxford University team.

RSS

Ads by Google

Font Size A+A-

Manmohan as Brown Sahib

Friday , February 06, 2009 at 00 : 04


Email PrintBlog
Ads by Google

In good health, Dr Manmohan Singh was dismissed by his critics as a 'weak' prime minister; in sickness, he is acknowledged as being indispensable to the ruling UPA.

That no single individual has been asked to fill in for the prime minister as he recovers from a heart surgery may reflect the insecurities of the Congress leadership, but it also does suggest that Dr Singh is now regarded as more than just first among equals.

And yet, when in around six weeks time, the prime minister is back on his feet, there is every possibility that the Congress and the UPA will have little time for Manmohan the campaigner in the run up to General Elections 2009.

For some strange reason, the Congress party has been reluctant to project the prime minister as an electoral asset. During the Karnataka elections in May 2008, for example, Dr Singh addressed just one election meeting, that too a closed door meeting confined to Congress workers in Bangalore. In the November 2008 elections, a few posters did spring up reminding the voter of the prime minister's important role in piloting the Indo-US nuclear deal.

But again, he wasn't a key campaigner, that role being confined once again to the Rahul-Sonia duo.

Part of the reluctance stems from the prime minister himself. As a self-confessed "accidental politician", Dr Singh has been distinctly uncomfortable with the demands of electoral politics. Perhaps, the defeat to Vijay Kumar Malhotra in the one Lok Sabha election he contested still rankles.

If middle class South Delhi chose to reject him then why should he now embrace the challenge of proving himself to be a vote-catching politician?

Someone needs to remind Dr Singh and his party that 2009 is not 1999. Dr Singh will be entering the Lok Sabha elections as only the second Congressman outside the Nehru-Gandhi family to have completed five years as prime minister.

Even if he has not been formally anointed as the UPA's prime ministerial choice, he does carry with him the considerable weight of his office. The Congress's rank and file may remain trapped in dynasty, the nation is not quite so susceptible, which is why the much-hyped Rahul era must wait its turn.

Moreover, while the soft-spoken Dr Singh may be ill at ease in large public gatherings, elections are more than just about fiery speeches.

There is, in fact, reason to believe that the Indian voter, especially in middle class urban areas, is searching for a meritocratic chief executive-like leader who will provide a calming influence, a compass to an uncertain future (witness the rise of Sheela Dikshit).

Trapped between a fear of being laid off and the threat of another terror attack, the urban voter is looking for someone who can guarantee a measure of economic and physical security.

This is where Dr Singh as a proven economic reformer has a unique opportunity to reach out to a large and influential constituency, to give them a sense of direction in times of financial worries.

This isn't just about reassuring Indian business, but also reassuring the aam admi. During the Hindustan Times leadership summit three months ago, Dr Singh made an able attempt to chart out a course of action that would sustain an eight per cent growth rate.

Unfortunately, the fine words have not been translated into the clear-headed decisions that are so desperately needed to energise the economy.

Perhaps Dr Singh hasn't been given the autonomy a chief executive needs to take the tough decisions, or is simply too fatigued to impose his writ on the coalition. If every move - be it insurance FDI, banking reform, pension deregulation, agricultural commodity pricing, public sector divestment - becomes a process of political compromise, then a certain lethargy is bound to filter through.

Moreover, how does one explain that critical infrastructure ministries like surface transport, telecom and power are headed by non-performing ministers unless its simply a case of obliging powerful political interests?

So far, Dr Singh's seeming lack of a mass base has been held against him. When you are a technocrat politician in a democratic set-up, then there is a certain dependence on the vote-gathering politicians that creeps in. It also builds a certain diffidence, heightened perhaps in Dr Singh's case by his genteel, non-combative working style.

And yet, if Dr Singh desires to transform himself into a mass leader in election season, then he could take heart from the British prime minister Gordon Brown.

Virtually written off politically a few months ago, Brown is the rising star in a global economic meltdown.At the heart of this turnaround has been Brown's strategy of bank recapitalisation - having governments provide capital to financial institutions in return for a share in ownership -- a bold, imaginative move designed to reinforce public confidence in a faltering economy.

In fact, the parallels between Dr Singh and the British prime minister are uncanny. Both are distinguished former finance ministers. Both inherited economies in a crisis, and both turned them around by making reform their mantra. Both benefited from education scholarships and started professional life as academics. Neither Dr Singh nor Brown can be described as natural, charismatic politicians by any stretch of imagination.

Both have worked in the shadow of others in public life: Dr Singh was first seen as Narasimha Rao's able minister, today he is positioned as Sonia Gandhi's prime ministerial appointee. For a decade, Brown's achievements paled under the magnetism of then prime minister Tony Blair.

In a way, both Dr Singh and Brown have almost preferred to be the number two men, politicians more comfortable in policy-making positions than being pushed into the cut and thrust of democratic politics.

And yet, accidents of history have catapulted them into leading their countries. Brown became prime minister only when Blair faltered in Iraq and gave up power. Dr Singh too is a beneficiary of similar self-renunciation.

Had Sonia Gandhi not heard her inner voice in the summer of 2004, Dr Singh would have remained a faithful cabinet minister. It has taken an economic crisis for Britain and the Labour party to truly 'accept' the leadership of Mr Brown and see him as an electable politician. The question now is, will the Congress party follow suit and have the courage to project the one individual who might just be their trump card this time?

Total Comments: 30

CollapsePosted 2009-02-14 04:27:57 : By balkrishna_a

Manmohan Singh is a respectable person, he has been outstanding finance minister. It is equally true that he is not a good leader and politician. That is why he was chosen to caretake PM seat for Rahul. It is very unfortunate for our country to have someone as PM because of his weaknesses instead of his strengths. ...Reply

CollapsePosted 2009-02-12 00:27:21 : By amhyd

Rajdeep excellent article, if there is one thing which India can boost about from our Political System, is our Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh, his clam is productive, and his patience is expressive. It is not always necessary to have very good firing speakers who can attract a political gathering and make them profusely clap.

It is very disrespecting as many label him has a yes man to Mrs. Sonia Gandhi. We are aware the compulsions of running a political party in a country like ours, with complex, political and national considerations to ride for five full years in a parliamentary democracy. The role played by Dr. Singh in the type of polity we nourish, is highly creditable.

I can not think of a person today who is as tall as Dr. Man Mohan Singh to the right choice for the 2009 candidate for Prime Minister Ship for Congress Party. Soon congress will announce his name as the there Prime Ministerial Candidate of 2009 Lok Sabha.

India, has seen, Terror as never before, economy going bunkers, recession touching its low, stock market showing signs of losing hope, inflation torching highs, political turmoil in the form of Nuclear Deal with U. S.

This Govt faired well on all tests and kept its cool and better sense in handling the available means.

With the hopeless economic index internationally, India, is considered as one of the most stable and safe nations when it comes to bonus back.

Dr. Sing has to be given the credit for the good work he has done and more so his able team members. The Captain of the Ship is wise too. In this case the captain is Sonia Gandhi. Let us not mention Rahul now as he is not in rush to jump in and spoil the show. He has time, on his side, his time will come.

www.adilmohd.com www.adilmohd.wordpress.com

...Reply

CollapsePosted 2009-02-11 18:20:11 : By salil mathur

Man Mohan Singh is India’s first Regent Prime Minister, who is in-charge while Rahul Gandhi grows up to his dynastic seat. He does not represent the people of India, as they never appointed him.

...Reply

CollapsePosted 2009-02-10 15:18:26 : By dilippanigrahy

Wish our prime minister in good health. To lead India we need a honest Leader like our pm but not weak like our pm who follows what party says. He should be dynamic lead the party.
As the election is nearer people will like to see the Prime Minister of India should be leader like Mr.Naveen patnaik (C.M. of Orissa)most sutable Prime ministerial candidate at present. ...Reply

CollapsePosted 2009-02-10 12:24:56 : By lavanya83

Informative as always. The parallel between Brown and MMS is very palpable. The issue remains the functioning of our democracy.
Though I do belive MMS could have been more authoratitve in certain situations (like the Terror Attack, The goondaism by Raj Thackery) but everything aside, he is very capable and a politican sans the "political issues". His actions have been curtailed by the co-alition and possible interference of the Gandhi Family.

Rahul is yet too young to appeal to the mass. Short-tempered, active and passionate; he still lacks the maturity which ccomes with age only. He is free spirited and that is appreaciated. Even as a youngester, I would still hesistate to bring in Rahul as a PM. Specially in these times. MMS can run for the post once more, and being from the electorate which rejected him,as you put it... I now strongly feel we will vote him back should he choose to stand. We need a leader with a mind and strong economic background, minus the pressures on him, and thats MMS for you.

No other leader to date holds a candle to him. ...Reply

DISCLAIMER
The views/ideas/opinions expressed in this section of the website www.ibnlive.com / www.ibnpolitics.com are solely those of the writer/author and not of Web18 Software Services Limited (Web18) or of IBN18 Broadcast Limited (IBN18). The statements made by the writer/author have not been verified in any manner by Web18 and/or IBN18. Web18 and/or IBN18 shall not be responsible for or liable in any manner whatsoever for the views/ideas/opinions expressed by the writer/author of this section.

About Us | Disclaimer | Careers @ IBN | RSS | Podcast | Contact Us | Feedback | Advertise With Us | Connect.in.com

© 2010 IBNLive.com India. All Rights Reserved. A Web18 Venture

CNN name, logo and all associated elements ® and © 2009 Cable News Network LP, LLLP. A Time Warner Company. All rights reserved. CNN and the CNN logo are registered marks of Cable News Network, LP LLLP, displayed with permission. Use of the CNN name and/or logo on or as part of CNN-IBN does not derogate from the intellectual property rights of Cable News Network in respect of them.