Total posts: 37
Display:

« Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 |

Tracked by 0 users Track this thread

Post your message
Lalgarh row: Is the Left Front losing control in West Bengal?

Lalgarh row: Is the Left Front losing control in West Bengal? | Read Story

TimePosted by IBNLive at 12:01 PM, Jun 18, 2009 in IBNPolitics

The Lalgarh episode in West Bengal has brought to focus the deteriorating law and order situation in the state. While the ruling Left Front has alleged that the Congress-Trinamool combine has been supporting Naxal activity in the area, the Union Railways Minister Mamata Banerjee has used this to press her demand for advancing Assembly elections. Is this the end of the road for the Left Front in West Bengal?

Posted by pks6 at 12:16 PM, Jun 19, 2009

Lalgarh problem started in 2007. CPM was in control at that time .They used to support (CPI - M - a part of CPM is maiosts) & latter kill the Maiosts/rebelians. There was a era of “Slow Poison” in The time of Jyoti Bose. Buddha is an Idiot, he neither follow Jyoti bose nor able to take any firm Stand. Party workers were frustrated with Pragmatic Buddha.
In 2009, Things gone beyond control. Already Nandigram, Singur are in the kitty & CPM know if Lalgarh is done - they would have gone by Now. So before election they played a politics of being keep quiet and support Chattradhar ( leader of the Movement) Chattradhar helped them by not participating in the Election. But every Dog has it's day and it is there Day.
Now Buddha & CPM want to come back with age old CPM medicine "Slow poision"-- delayed all the activities and solowly kill the leaders... but it is too late...... they have to pay a price , and a Huge price.
Bengal has another problem of East Bengal and Ghati \" (Midnapore is considered to be a area of Ghati , Lower class ) There is a distinct division of the two. Last 32 years these East Bengalalies { basically “Bangladeshi” } has suppressed the other region of Bengal Now it is the turn of the other side : Changed has already started \" will take little time.]


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by ranisuri123 at 09:34 AM, Jun 19, 2009

The Left Front will lose control of Bengal. What worries me is the lax attitude of the Centre (UPA)in rooting out the maoists and naxals. Their tentacles are spreading far and wide yet we dont send in trained cops with proper arms and ammo but lathi yielding cops a few of which may have the vintage .303 rifles.
The UPA govt is going to fail the people in security matters once again.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by vinayakapran at 09:51 PM, Jun 18, 2009

Till now what Left front were telling that they are pro-poor, is almost rubbish. If they were pro-poor,there would no situation like this which is happening in Lalgarh.

Left front lost some grip during Nandigram and Singur, Next losing very badly in Lok Sabha elections. Now with Lalgarh issue,Left front government will completely loose the grip in WB.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by deepanjanmitra at 09:36 PM, Jun 18, 2009

In the midst of the fury, the decision whether the left is LEFT OUT in Bengal or the right is ALL THAT RIGHT is not possible to make.
There was a time when we used to say: "What Bengal thinks today, India will think tomorrow"(Gokhale)It is true for even the Naxal movements in 70's when the ideological excellence did attract the best of the brains from country. It is this left Govt who stood by them at that point of time and later on did nothing to support the Naxal's ideology. The best of the brains dissociate themselves from the SO CALLED left govt in West Bengal therafter and though seemed to go in oblivion; now they are showing their strength all again.(But don't match those Naxals with these)

we should go deep into the matter. What is the state sponsored terrorism and violence that West bengal has experienced in past so many years? People were made to support the party even if they are/were not willing to do so.....I remember my school days when the SFI used to stand at the gates of school to raise funds for their organisation and we had no option but to donate money for the party funds! Is not it terrorism? The silent sophisticated threat and watchdog behaviour of the cadres have become so violent in recent times that they even dictate which news paper you read at home!!!

The upsurge of this unrest is thus the tremendous social oppression by the cadres and their leaders. I believe, no educated society will support the acts of violence what is now going on. What is now important is not just to tide over the crisis but a serious introspection of the facts by the party.

Similarly, the opposition should also not try taking any advantage out of the situation. They must remember that "History repeats itself". So they should not behave irresponsibly. Rather the people has given a revolutionary mandate this time what they should en-cash in order to help the Govt this moment and show their solidarity in the act.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by raktimganguly at 09:29 PM, Jun 18, 2009

It is quite possible that the anarchy in West Midnapore is being stagemanaged by the central dispensation.It is also noteworthy that similar rumblings are being heard in the closed tea estates of North Bengal(in the Dooars and the Terai region.The Darjeeling hills are already beyond the Left Front government's control. If anybody is to be blamed for this, then it is the party or combine which has ruled for more than three decades but could not deliver the fruits of development even to the urban poor.Their party-centric and myopic policies have taken the state to abysmal depths. Here people die of hunger even when other states with lower Human Development Indices march ahead.The people want a viable and mature opposition.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by yasir-mohammed at 06:54 PM, Jun 18, 2009

One cannot do politics on moist holding up in parts of w.b, it is the most serious situation as the moist are a bigger threat to India then any other organization.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

  lessPosted by mprithviraj at 05:32 PM, Jun 18, 2009

Large numbers of Maoists are Adivasis who are said to be fighting against exploitation and oppressions which refuse us the luxury of ignoring the plight of the sovereigns (Politicians, Police, Forest Administrators, and Money Lender etc.)

It seems most of us are not informed well. The agenda of Congress Lead Government (CLG former UPA) and Maoists are same as for as for Aam Admi (common man) where as Government only TALK and Maoists ACT.

To deal with this issue, we may have to recall MKGandhi who can calm the stormy agitations and fighting.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by tarshid at 06:02 PM, Jun 18, 2009

very well to sound but a fasle interpretation of depiction. there is none so bloody idiocy than destroying our homeland by our people and insane people support it by saying it is justified. what are we becoming, lunatics of a modern era who is educated so much that his brains fuse and he ends up torching his own house. to settle this there should be an end to violence and means to do so is to crush it.


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

Posted by gg123.93 at 04:23 PM, Jun 18, 2009

The deteorating law and order is not happening on its own.There is an extreme right wing and extreme left wing nexus who are orchestrating this situation.they are trying to create an atmosphere and civil war like situation all over Bengal in order to impose the Presidents rule. It is a ploy to remove a democratically elected government by force.And some force with very deep pocket is providing the money power for all these.Because they know that in a free and fair election they have a very slim chance to win.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

  lessPosted by bapi15 at 03:45 PM, Jun 18, 2009

No way...no one can end the reign of left front in west bengal....bcoz they created this beautuful bengal...


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by raktimganguly at 09:19 PM, Jun 18, 2009

Don't loose hope. This beautiful Bengal is already on the way to throw these demons out.Their end will be as pathetic as their reign.


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

  lessPosted by karavadi raghav at 02:36 PM, Jun 18, 2009

Politicians who are in power think that they will be eternally in power.Thinking in that direction they do many mistakes.They want to ruin their immediate opponents. for that they create some new forces.They will grow and harm those created. One can remember the story of Demon Bhasmasura who wanted to test the boon granted by Lord Shiva ( The boon is on whoever's head the demon puts his hand that verso would be reduced to ashes).Lord Vishnu in the shape of MoHINI ( A charming lady) played a trick and saw that the Demon put his hand on his own head and got himself reduced to ashes. Late Kamaraja Nadar patronized DK and DMK that later ousted the Congress from TamilNadu.The congress bosses in Maharashtra patronized the Shiva Sena which became a sharp sword in the bed of the congress now.The Late Indira Gandhi to beat the Akalidal propped up the Late Bindra wale and terrorists due to which Punjab suffered for years and Indira Gandhi was assassinated.The more one stays in power his or her going out of power will be worse. Maoists came from CPM Only.The CPM's leaders of yesteryear are the GURUS of Maoists next to the Late Maotsetung.CPM is paying back fro the bad it did.The Trinamool of Mamatha and the congress will contribute to this wild fire for which they aslo will pay a big price.

karavadi raghav


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by nuthakkiarkay at 03:46 PM, Jun 18, 2009

COMMUNIST PARTY OF INDIA AT CERTAIN POINT INTO CPI AND CPI-M,

BASING ON THEIR IDEOLOGICAL DIFFERENCES.

AFTER THAT SOME COMRADES WERE DISILLUSIONED WITH DEMOCRACY

AND ELECTORAL POLITICS AND REALISING THAT COMMUNISM CAN BE

ESTABLISHED ONLY THRO`ARMED STRUGGLE,TOOK VARIOUS NAMES BUT

FINALLY GOT A COMMON IDENTITY AS MAOISTS.

THE BHASMASURA EPISODE DOES NOT THROW ANY LIGHT OR SOLUTION

TO THIS PROBLEM AND ONLY SOLUTION WOULD BE THE REACHING OF

THE SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT ACROSS ALL SECTIONS OF PEOPLE.

ANYTHING ELSE IS THAT WE ARE CHEATING OURSELVES.


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

Posted by sujmatp at 03:16 PM, Jun 18, 2009

Thats right...politians who don't work for the people....well...the people will give them a work out!


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

« Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 |

ibnlive.com on mobile: Join debate, leave voice messages on m.ibnlive.com

  • Active Users

srikantiah (4460 posts)

raomeister (4004 posts)

sbhattacharjee (3326 posts)

kkameswaraniyer (2911 posts)

sivaraman89 (2002 posts)

tpod (1814 posts)

shanthanu4640 (1671 posts)

jay1jay1jay1 (1666 posts)