Total posts: 105
Display:

« Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 |

Tracked by 0 users Track this thread

Post your message
Should Class X Boards be scrapped?

Should Class X Boards be scrapped? | Read Story

TimePosted by IBNLive at 01:08 PM, Jun 25, 2009 | Updated at 01:09 PM, Jun 25, 2009 in IBNPolitics

It is still a germ of an idea, but if the Union HRD Minister Kapil Sibal has his way, Class X Board exams may be a thing of the past. Sibal has come has come up with a innovative idea to reform school education system and is planning to scrap the Class 10 board examination. Instead, he wants to set up an evaluation system based on percentiles. Do you think scrapping Class X Board exams is a practical idea? Will this affect the quality of education?

  lessPosted by privarsh at 04:55 PM, Jun 25, 2009

The Examination system to all classes and especially the common public Exam for X stand should be modified. There should be examinations only from Class VI at school level. Public Examination should be there once for VIII Standard and another for XII standard. The Xth std. public examination should be scrapped. The Matriculation and SSLC should be merged and a common syllabus should be given. The medium of instruction should be in their mother tongue and English and any other language should be taught to all with a special care for English coaching. Our Education policy should undergo a massive change to suit the needs of Indian condition. Mahakavi Bharathi has prescribed a syllabus for "National Education" upto V std. and what are all the subjects to be taught are also there. We should follow it for our primary students.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by pavanmgr at 12:04 AM, Jun 26, 2009

I welcome the decision to some extent. My view point is that more than marks, the burden which is laid on the young minds with expectations from parents is what causing children to feel that extra pressure. Fine scrapping of exams will make many students happy. But we need to have some thing concrete as an alternative to exams. We need to have some means to measure the performance of children.

One alternative is to have a system where exams(not the routine ones where the student is just asked to replicate his memory, but a mix of memory retention questions, questions where one needs to use creativity, questions where ones experience also matters) are conducted, along with it other extra curricular activity related exams are also conducted. Rather than providing marks, we can have a counselling session kind where in a student is provided feedback individually based on his performance in all the activities. Based on the feedback the student can be advised to choose a field. But for all this to happen parents should be convinced that all the fields have equal importance, not just engineering or MBA.


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

  lessPosted by sforsumeet at 04:53 PM, Jun 25, 2009

Current Rating:

It is a great idea by Mr.Sibal


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by rahulnair25283 at 05:37 PM, Jun 25, 2009

This is a wonderful idea Mr. Union HRD Minister. Any which ways out board exams are hopeless in the method of implementation and evaluation. There needs to be a change in the education system and what better than re-structuring the 10th std exams. Infact it would be great if the entire education system could be overhauled. Students should never feel school education as an obligation to be forcefully fulfilled.


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

  lessPosted by nischaykalra at 04:44 PM, Jun 25, 2009

Scrapping the Xth board exam is a very bad idea. But there needs to be changes in the present system. It should be more practical. Scrapping will lead to compromising the Quality of our students. We all know that the Indian students are one of the best in world and even US president Obama accepted it in his speech few days before. The Xth board is the stepping stone of their life. The government should change the format from 100%Theroy system to 60:40 system i.e. 60 marks for theory and 40 for practicals. The Government should try to increase the quality of Govt. school rather than making the things more worse and complicated. I would like to ask Mr.Sibal that how will the college admission get more complicated and confusing due to scrapping of boards? Due to this students will not get admission in the college they want. What about them. Now also there is a lot of complicated due to Quata system. Mr.Sibal should do something about that!


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by satyamravindra at 10:31 PM, Jun 25, 2009

Rightly said, scrapping X board exams means compromising on the quality of education. The board exams are providing students glimps of the road ahead, this should continue as it is.


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

Posted by surajit_s17 at 04:32 PM, Jun 25, 2009

It's an interesting and great idea that has come in Mr. Sibal's mind. It is true that board exam in class X is already a burden to both student and parents. Little children are sick of this exam system as the exam demands too much from them. Examination becomes symbol of fear to the pupils. Students don't enjoy study if examination becomes the ultimate destiny at the age of fifteen. He also thinks of bringing percentile concept by eliminating percentage marks system - another good idea. He is trying to make the education more enjoyable so that young boys and girls will cherish their study, will gain true effective knowledge. Very good. But, Mr. Sibal needs to look into other important things to implement his new idea effectively. He must ensure the uniformity and quality of education throughout the country. Otherwise, neglected areas will remain ignored. If he has real ambition to bring our children to the global forum with highest standard of skill and competency, he must do lot of other drastic changes in the overall primary, secondary and higher secondary education system which includes admission procedure & criteria, recruitment of teachers, teaching style, performance review of students and teachers too in addition to overhaul of present curriculum. He must stop money flow in education system with utmost sincerity and honesty. He must make everybody responsible and accountable for their role in education system including parents, teachers and administrators for the sake of development of nation. Good luck to Mr. Sibal for his innovative thinking, but he has to do lot more for the huge country.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by pmisgr8 at 04:30 PM, Jun 25, 2009

This is definitely a way of securing votes and destroying the future of so many. The HRD minister is misleading students. admissions into good colleges will get tougher just like getting into IIT. This idea will destroy the educational system the world envies. while Barack Obama is asking Americans to look out for indians, our own leaders are playing with the lives of students. We citizens are the reason that they are sitting in their offices.What a fine way of showing gratitude!
The UPA and Congress have shown that they haunt common man's every step.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

  lessPosted by karunganni at 03:54 PM, Jun 25, 2009

the congress fellows have quixotic ideas.mr sibal wants an evaluation sysytem?like that in sonia's party in choosing the candidates for contesting the elections and becoming ministers?it all started with indira doing away with existing systems,authorities etc etc.let mr sibal arrange proper buildings for the schools blackboards teachers proper sanitation and drinking water facilities for all the schools first


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by buteofalcon at 05:02 PM, Jun 25, 2009

dude, I agree that we have a long way to go. But these reforms have to start somewhere. So if possible, can you be a bit positive in supporting the government with better reforms? Atleast they are trying to do something. Let them.


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

Posted by sambitlnt at 11:30 PM, Jun 25, 2009

what are they trying to do ? Scrap Xth board exam ? One of the very imp reason why we study hard is to get good marks in the board exam so that we can get into good institutions.
Now if you scrap off board exam

- what will be the basis of selection for those good institutions ? Will all of them have their own entrance or a common entrance ? Internal assessment is out of question coz all schools will give good marks to their students

If that is the case then instead of board exam the students will feel the pressure of that entrance so the pressure factor will always be there.

Another factor is only until class X we study all the subject irrespective of what branch/trade we are going to be in the future. So we need to know all the subjects thoroughly (Science, history, civics, Geography etc) to make an intelligent choice when the choice is confronted i.e. after Xth. If the exams are taken away, you know how hard we will study.

Last but not the least, what kind of undue pressure you guys are talking about. I have passed my Xth exam and so have millions of other guys. Yes we do stretch ourselves a bit more than regular but that is what life is all about. You can't expect to be in a bed of roses all through your life. To gain something you have to work hard and remember there is no shortcut to success. If Xth board exams are putting undue pressure on students, think about IIT-JEE. Even at an age of 17 people are not that matured to take all those pressure. So should we scrap that also ??

Why all HRD ministers are so foolish (I did not want ot use this word as he is 10000 times more learned than me, but why is he giving such statements?? )


Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

Posted by simranmohanty at 02:51 PM, Jun 25, 2009

I THINK THAT U SHOULD COMPLETLY CUT THIS BOARDS SINCE 8 ITSELF .CHILREN R GIVEN A LOT OF PRESSURE BLOODILY N 10 BOARD EXAMS ADD A LOT ITS MY SINCERE REQUEST IF U WANT THE WELL BEING OF CHILREN ,,,,THEN PLEASE DO CANCEL IT PLEASE DO SEROIUSLY MAN.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

  lessPosted by svsm at 01:40 PM, Jun 25, 2009

Kapil Sibal has done a great deed by just thinking of eliminating grade ten board exams from the education system in India. It is indeed a great pressure for students, parents and teachers... who are under great pressure to finish the syllabus on time. However, he must also shift his attention to ICSE schools as well. After all a large number of students study in ICSE schools in Kolkata, Bombay and Lucknow. Students in ICSE schools have to manage a huge number of projects along with the pressure of class tests and regular preparation for boards. The minister does need to amend this big time. May be scraping the Xboard exams may not be the best option, but definitely the education system here does need revamping.
The HRD committee has also made it compulsory to give GRE exams for seat in college. This is a very good step it has taken, but he should also address the fact that colleges require donations and this is a problem to be addressed. Isn’t the fees given by students enough to run it that they need donations, or is it that nothing in India can be done without bribe.
If Mr. Sibal’s committee is trying to revamp the education sys, then two things need to be looked at urgently as well....
1. Education in ICSE schools needs to be looked at. Students who study there are also citizens of India and also the future of the country.
2. The fact that donations have to be given to colleges and because of this a lot of people miss out on admission even after getting a good percentage.


Reply to this post Rate this post Track User Click if Offensive

Posted by gopalidm at 09:33 PM, Jun 25, 2009

Hi there...

It is this pressure of Schooling.. which is fuelling the ammunition for INDIA to be super power..
WHy do u think. INDIANS are inteliigent ? it is bcoz of this school educatin.. which is very tight.. strict.. & difficult...

We cant afford.. pressureless education.. Students get diverted very easily.. if they have no pressure.. @ school... and we dont have better opportunities for non - acedemic careers ...

we cant afford as Parents to ask our pupils to pursue career in Cricket / Atheletics / Swimming etc... bcoz.. INDIA has less scope to this...

Once we are a developed nation.. and can afford such careers.. then chnage education system... the CUrrent educatin system is solving its purpose...

may be... Upper class ppl feel.. there childs are going thru roigh.. wich is un-necessary..as they are self- satisfied.. but dont carry on this self-satisfcation on to middle class... and poor ppl.. as they nned more of such challenges...

Kapil Sibbal sir... wear.. a common man;s parent CAP..
You have to take action as a PARENT.. and not as STUDENT .. in ths regard.. especiaaly !



Reply to this post | Rate this post | Track User | Click if Offensive

« Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 |

ibnlive.com on mobile: Join debate, leave voice messages on m.ibnlive.com

  • Active Users

srikantiah (4460 posts)

raomeister (4004 posts)

sbhattacharjee (3326 posts)

kkameswaraniyer (2911 posts)

sivaraman89 (2002 posts)

tpod (1814 posts)

shanthanu4640 (1671 posts)

jay1jay1jay1 (1666 posts)