Birth of a debate: The abortion dilemma

FAMILY MATTERS: Face the Nation panelists discuss whether parents should be allowed to abort pregnancy.

      

ibnlive.com is on mobile now. Read news, watch videos
be a Citizen Journalist. Log on to m.ibnlive.com NOW!

Top Headlines

Top Videos

Most Popular

• I took calculated risks for higher growth: Pranab  

• Udayan's View: Budget 2009, a game of patience 

• A study in comparison: Education budget up Rs 7K cr 

• Face The Budget: Political response to Budget 2009-10 

• The verdict: CNN-IBN panelists rate Pranab's Budget  

• Reform hopes dashed, market watchers feel let down  

• I-T exemption limit raised | FBT rolled back | Taxes and you 

• Pranab skips two paras of Budget speech, apologises 

• Bengal benefits, Mamata and Pranab budget for their state 

• Income tax limits raised; farmers, exporters get sops 

• Watch: Dalal Street reacts to the Budget 

• Budget: Pranab's chance to create his own legacy 

• FM has done a fairly good job: Narayana Murthy 

• Budget to focus on social spend, growth 

• Education reform will be for all Indians: Sibal 

• The Budget That Isn't: Cyrus gears up for Budget 

• EVMs are tamper proof, says Election Commission 

• Watch: Railway exams disrupted in Mysore, Banglaore 

• Watch: Maneka writes to PM over threat to Varun's life 

• One-upmanship: Sonia, Pawar in foodgrain politics 

• Life saving drugs, LCDs cheaper; Set-top-box costlier 

• Buy that big car: SUVs, petrol trucks to cost less 

• Defence budget unchanged; Army gets lion's share 

• Minimum Rs 30 lakh needed to be called wealthy 

• TAX BREAKS, WELFARE SCHEMES IN COMMON MAN'S BUDGET 

• Common man gets a treat, over 15 schemes 

• Health budget up by Rs 4,000 cr, 6 new AIIMS in cities 

• Full text: Union Budget 2009 

• Bengal benefits, Mamata and Pranab budget for their state 

• Software industry gets tax benefits for one more yr 

Photogallery

Find us on Facebook | Join IBNLive community

Stay ahead with G-Talk Buddy | Click now!

The Bombay High Court on Monday rejected Niketa and Harish Mehta’s plea to abort their 24-week-old foetus, which the doctors say may have a congenital heart defect. The Court ruled that a predicted disability is no ground for abortion.

The Mehtas argued that they believe they won’t be able to afford to care for the baby or endure the trauma, and, therefore, they should be allowed to terminate the life of their unborn baby.

But is abortion a matter of parental choice? CNN-IBN raised that question on its show Face the Nation. On the panel to discuss the issue were founders, Uday Foundation, Tulika and Rahul Verma; Convener, Disabled Rights Group, Javed Abidi; General Secretary, Society for the Right to Die with Dignity, Dr Surendra Dhelia; and Head of Foetal Medicine, Apollo, Dr Anita Kaul.

Show’s moderator Sagarika Ghose initiated the discussion by asking that if it’s the parents who are the primary care givers to a child and it’s them who’ll be traumatised if the child passes on because of the disability, why should they not be at liberty to decide whether they want to have the baby or not?

Javed Abidi said no one’s contesting the right of the parents. “The question is,” he said, “until when is it okay to terminate a pregnancy. Indian law does not law abortion after 20 weeks of conception. In Mehta’s case, the foetus is already 24 weeks old. So if we take a liberal stand on the issue today then what stops a parent tomorrow to abort a child just a day before the delivery, on the grounds of fear of disability or some other aspect such as the face or the skin of the child?”

Underscoring the fact that it is merely a possibility and not a certainty that the child will has a congenital disease, Abidi said, “I have seen many examples, where the doctors predicted a congenital defect but the child was born normal.” He added, “ Experts say that one in 10 child has a congenital heart issue. Are we trying to say that one tenth of our children should be killed because of that fear?”

Dr Anita Kaul, however, said that the question is not whether abortion should be allowed or not. “A 24-week-old foetus is born with signs of life; before that, it’s a still birth. Therefore, we are saying the parents should have a choice is up to 24 weeks.

Technology Vs Ethics

Strongly opposing the doctor’s point of view, Rahul Verma, father of a child with a congenital defect, said, “It’s not a matter of choice. We are not talking about choosing a car or a holiday spot. Citing the example of “miracle-child” Lakshmi, who was born with eight limbs, Rahul said, “We are talking about a life and that too the life of a human baby.”