ibnlive » Books » Reviews

'Ministry of Hurt Sentiments' is a hurt voice through the pages


Palki S Upadhyay,CNN-IBN
Oct 29, 2012 at 01:02pm IST

It's a poem. It's a story. It's many stories strung into one. All morbid and dark. With tragic ends and injustice. Stories about the unfairness of life. The greed and cruelty of men.

Stories you hear all the time.

It talks about religion and politics, rapists and molestors, drugs, dreams and death, the land mafia and the protesting tribals, apathy and decay, the stench of Mumbai, its ugly face or "fanny splayed open like a mouth at a dentist's office. All are welcome to sniff and prod and examine. All are welcome to move in if the smell is to one's liking."

'Ministry of Hurt Sentiments' is a hurt voice

Ministry of Hurt Sentiments is too shrill and bitter - a brave attempt but don't read it in one go.

It's gross. And beyond a point it stops jolting your sensitivity. Like the beggar kids near the traffic light. You see them, you ignore them. You're not bad. You just learn to see them as part of the landscape. Altaf Tyrewala puts Mumbai under the microscope. He is cynical. He is precise. He observes closely. He seems to see only the negative. Perhaps it makes for more powerful writing. I'm afraid he may have overdone it.

Ministry of Hurt Sentiments is the picture of a city, painted in dark, broad strokes.

"Seen through the steam from a five-buck cup of cutting

The future flaps around like a headless chicken

Spraying out iPods and hi-speed petrol"

A city that swears and seethes, suffers and inflicts suffering.

"Behind empathy-proof Skoda windows

Ride diamond-studded brittle egos

Cut them up and they'll f----ing cut you up

And dump you by the road next to Marx's mangled remains"

It's a hurt voice that, through the pages, turns into a tirade. Don't read it in one go. It's too shrill and bitter. But do give it a chance. It's a brave attempt.

Book: Ministry of Hurt Sentiments; By: Altaf Tyrewala; Price: Rs. 299; Format: Hardback; Extent: 104 pages; Category: Fiction

Latest

More from this section

PREVIOUS  'The Edge of the Machete' is skillfully crafted, sloppily told

NEXT  'Sounding Off' is simple, brisk and engaging