NANO NIGHTMARE FOR BENGAL
States roll out the red carpet for TATA, Nano
Published on Sat, Aug 23, 2008 at 17:00, Updated on Sat, Aug 23, 2008 at 20:12 in Business section
Tags: West Bengal, Singur , New Delhi
![]() |


Related Stories
HC bars security forces from leaving Shopian
Dehradun cops accused of killing man to win medals
CPI-M may decide feuding Kerala leaders' fate
CM helpless, admits Maoists extort Rs 300 cr annually
Bandh call by Hindu outfit gets mixed response in Mysore
Time for Mamata to walk the Budget talk 
Mamata's Budget Express | Mamata Exclusive | Rail Budget
Top bosses fly high as AI struggles to survive 
10 years of Kargil, heroes recall the war | Pay Tribute 
Cabinet split over order legalising homosexuality 
New Delhi: West Bengal's loss could well be - Maharashtra, Orissa or even Karnataka's.
A day after Ratan Tata - the father of the Rs 1 lakh car,Nano - threatened to move the project lock, stock and barrel out of Singur, other state government's are rolling out the red carpet for the Rs 1,500 crore project.
"I could read from Ratan Tata's statement that he is troubled in West Bengal so I invited him to come here instead and we will give him a red carpet welcome. There are a lot of probable sites for the Nana project in Maharashtra. We have a mega-project policy in Maharashtra and whatever concessions there are in that policy will be given to the TATAs if they decided to come here," Mahrashtra Chief Minister, Vilasrao Deshmukh said.
"We will offer a market price to the farmers and give proper compensation for their land. All problems related to land acquisition for industry have become synonymous with the state of West Bengal," he added.
Meanwhile, Orissa Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik too is echoing the invitation. "Orissa is willing to consider the Nano project if TATA approaches us," he said.
Orissa's Industry Minister, Biswa Bhusan Harichandan has criticised the Left-ruled West Bengal government for being desperate to retain the Nano project in the state, but at the same time, the same Left parties are protesting various other mega projects in Orissa.
"TATA has already acquired a lot of land at Bhopalpur in Orissa. This could be the probable site for Nano if TATA agrees," said Harichandan.
But it's easier said than done. The TATAs already have a mega steel plant project at Kalinganagar which couldn't even start construction work thanks to stiff protests for the last three years. Fourteen tribals have already died in police firing during protests.
Simultaneously, the Punjab government has invited a delegation of the TATA group for a formal meeting with the Chief Minister so that every aspect of the proposed plant could be discussed.
"I will soon write an offer letter to TATA Group to formally invite them to install its Nano plant in Punjab, for which every possible facility will be provided by the state government," says state Industry Minister, Manoranjan Kalia.
"The state would make one of the best available offers to the TATAs. Once the offer is discussed in a threadbare manner, every issue would be sorted out," he added.
But it is Dharwad in Karnataka that sources say the TATA's may chose to move thier nano project to. Dharwad already has a TATA unit.
But with 80 per cent of the project aleady complete, West Bengal Chief Minister, Buddhadeb Bhatcharjee, would be hoping against hope that the People's Car rolls out of Singur this October. And for that to happen he will have to ensure that Mamata Bannerjee's indefinite protests begining on Sunday remain peaceful.
(With inputs from Raksha Shetty in Mumbai and Jajati Karan in Orissa)
| Ads by Google |
| Related Ads: | |
















Read Comment | Post Comment
It was an error of judgement on Mr Ratan Tata's part to even think of West Bengal for his Nano
Read Comment
I feel states like Karnataka,Orissa,Maharshtra are more safer states than W.Bengal or Kerala for the Tatas to invest for their
Read Comment
Where is Ms. Mamta Banerjee today ?
Read Comment
It will not be worthwhile to placate Ms.Bannerjee to a compromise and face her constant agitation on every issue.Mr.Tata has
Read Comment
I am happy that Tata's are not left High and dry, Even I am concerned of eco system being disturbed,
Read Comment
Read more comment »